Killer Pies Menu (Update 2026)

Killer Pies offers a menu that satisfies every pizza lover. The star of the show is the classic NY-style pizza, featuring a thin, crispy crust that holds up to generous portions of toppings. Popular choices include the pepperoni slice and the marinara pizza, perfect for a quick bite.

Not in the mood for pizza? Sandwich lovers will delight in options like The Italian and the Meatball Parm. For those seeking something fresh, the killer salads provide a delicious balance, with the Buffalo Chicken Salad making a strong case for topping that list.

Don’t miss the gluten-free pizza option, catering to dietary needs without compromising on taste. Prices range around $15 to $16, making it an affordable dining choice. With 19 different dishes to choose from, there is something for everyone at this Asbury Park hotspot.

Killer Pies Menu image 1
Killer Pies Menu image 2
Killer Pies Menu image 3
Killer Pies Menu image 4
Killer Pies Menu image 5
Killer Pies Menu image 6
Killer Pies Menu image 7
Killer Pies Menu image 8
Killer Pies Menu image 9
Killer Pies

Killer Pies Interior, Food, Ambiance

Walking into Killer Pies, you’ll find a relaxed atmosphere filled with local artwork and a friendly vibe. The space feels inviting, perfect for a casual meal or a relaxed gathering with friends.

The aroma of baking pizza fills the air, making it hard to resist trying a slice right away. Seating is spacious, creating an inviting spot to enjoy a meal or chat with friends over a salad or slice of that killer pie.

Overall, the ambiance combines comfort and creativity, reflecting the spirit of Asbury Park. Whether it’s a late-night craving for a quick slice or a family dinner, Killer Pies welcomes all with open arms.

Killer Pies

About Killer Pies Food and Specialties

Killer Pies delivers classic comfort food with an innovative twist. Their pizzas are renowned for a perfect blend of cheese, sauce, and crust that create satisfying flavors with every bite. The pepperoni slice has fans raving, often flying out of the kitchen to eager customers.

For those looking for something a bit different, the spinach pie showcases a savory balance of fresh ingredients that pleases the palate. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring the quality remains consistent and delightful.

The Killer Pie stands out, a unique blend of flavors that may surprise fans of traditional pizza. Innovative offerings abound, making each visit an opportunity to explore something new and tasty. With average prices just a touch over $15, it feels like a culinary steal.

Killer Pies

Killer Pies stands committed to delivering quality while fostering a love for pizza. Each dish highlights fresh, carefully sourced ingredients, ensuring every bite bursts with flavor. The restaurant specializes in New York-style pizza but plays with creative toppings and options, appealing to both traditionalists and adventurers alike. The vision behind Killer Pies centers on building community. Every pizza crafted aims to create a shared experience among friends and family. With a focus on inclusivity, the menu incorporates gluten-free options, allowing everyone to enjoy their signature pies. It's not just about feeding people; it's about bringing them together over a love of great food and community spirit.