Killer Pies

Discover Killer Pies Pizza in Asbury Park, NJ, offering delicious NY-style, thin crust, gluten-free, and specialty pizzas like pepperoni slices, marinara, spinach pies, and green pizza. Enjoy the killer pie experience today!

Welcome to Killer Pies

Taste the Difference.

Killer Pies
Killer Pies
Killer Pies
Killer Pies

Tucked away on Mattison Avenue in Asbury Park, Killer Pies offers a slice of life worth sharing. Known for its exceptional New York-style pizza, this inviting restaurant serves up a delicious fusion of classics and creative toppings that draw locals and visitors alike. Whether you're craving a crispy pepperoni slice or a vibrant green pizza loaded with veggies, Killer Pies has something for every palate.

The atmosphere buzzes with excitement from the aroma of fresh pies baking in the oven, making it a perfect spot for friends to gather or families to enjoy a meal. Plus, with gluten-free options available, everyone can partake in the pizza party at Killer Pies.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

649 Mattison Ave, Asbury Park, NJ 07712, United States

Phone

+1 732-455-3100

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Killer Pies
Killer Pies
Killer Pies
Killer Pies

Killer Pies isn't just a pizza restaurant; it epitomizes the essence of community dining in Asbury Park. Opened as a local hub for pizza lovers, this establishment is built on a foundation of fresh ingredients, passion for flavor, and a commitment to customer satisfaction. The cozy interior features an eclectic decor that reflects the quirky charm of the area, making it a visually appealing destination for patrons.

Customers often rave about the perfectly baked crust that strikes a balance between crispiness and chewiness, which forms the backbone of its legendary pies. The pizza menu shines with options like the pepperoni slice and gluten-free pizzas, appealing to diverse dietary needs. Each pie is crafted with attention to detail and has become a staple for regulars and first-timers alike.

In addition to pizzas, the restaurant boasts an impressive selection of sandwiches and salads, providing a well-rounded dining experience. Casual dining here means an open invitation to share slices, stories, and laughter, creating lasting memories. Killer Pies also embraces a spirit of innovation by introducing new flavors and seasonal ingredients, ensuring that every visit feels fresh and exciting.

Catering to the fast-paced lifestyle of its clientele, Killer Pies offers a quick and convenient service without compromising quality. Whether it’s a family dinner or a late-night snack with friends, there’s a familiar warmth that envelops diners, making it a beloved spot in the vibrant Asbury Park scene.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

Killer Pies prides itself on a comprehensive menu designed to cater to a variety of tastes. Diners can savor a range of pizzas, from the classic thin crust to specialty pies like the marinara and spinach pie. The sandwich offerings, including The Bond and Meatball Parm, add a hearty twist for those looking for something different. With a delightful selection of salads, such as the Killer Salad and Caesar Salad, patrons can opt for a lighter meal. Each dish showcases fresh ingredients, making every bite a treat. The average price of $15.58 ensures that everyone can enjoy quality food without breaking the bank.

What's more, the ability to order pizza by the slice makes it an ideal stop for a quick lunch during a busy day. The casual yet vibrant atmosphere draws a crowd, allowing for both cheerful chatter and delicious dining.

Killer Pies

The exterior of Killer Pies captures the lively spirit of Asbury Park with its bright signage and welcoming outdoor seating. Nestled among other enticing eateries, this spot invites passersby with the tantalizing smells of fresh pizza and the buzz of happy diners. The outdoor area provides the perfect backdrop for enjoying a slice under the sun or under the stars, contributing to the engaging, community-oriented vibe.

Inside, the restaurant features an eclectic mix of decor that mirrors the artistic essence of Asbury Park—think quirky pizza murals and comfortable seating that encourages diners to gather and enjoy their meals at a leisurely pace. The atmosphere radiates warmth and friendliness, making it a popular hangout spot for locals.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

First learned of Killer Pies on a gluten-free in New Jersey facebook group - and I can say that the gluten-free slices (and can be ordered as a whole pie) are worth the hype! Sicilian-like slices! So good! They also offer gluten slices and pies, as well as great salads. Fantastic and friendly service, too!

L
Lauren C.

New pizza joint in town. Love their whole vibe. Really embraced the Asbury Park feel. The inside is beautiful. Love their branding. My friends got a pie to go and said it was good. If they could expand and offer vegan cheese/toppings they could hit off even better by offering to vegans! They do have a vegan pie but it's just red sauce pie. In a town like Asbury were almost every place offers banging vegan choices- I feel this could REALLY elevate them.

H
Heather B.

Killer Pies in Asbury Park lives up to its reputation. I've been hearing for a while about the killer gluten-free crust they offer here. It is nothing like any other GF pizza I've had anywhere - in a really great way! Thick, tasty crust with a really satisfying, focaccia-like crunch to the edge and chew in the middle. Tasty toppings. Awesome service. Open late. I loved my first visit, and can't wait to return. I forgot to take a photo before we attacked our half-pepperoni, half-veg pie - this is what came home with us afterward.

J
Jennifer M.

Hands down a way better pizza than JMacs. For a few bucks, you can order by the slice which is a rarity in Asbury Park. Great locals vibe, down to earth service, and great selection of slices thats affordable. Open late night a huge plus. Skip the line elsewhere

D
Dan S.

One of the best pizza places in the area, every person behind that counter is super friendly and kind. They care about the little things like making sure you have ice and a cup for your can of soda, making sure your slices or whole pie is good. The vibe and decor of the place are the icing on the cake for this pizza shop. It's our go to when we want consistently good pizza. The pepperoni pizza is my classic fav there

B
Bridget

Hands down best pizza in and around Monmouth county. We tried multiple pies but my favorite was the gluten free - total perfection. The soda flavors were super unique and so much fun, there's nothing like this experience anywhere else. Everyone who worked there was beyond friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful, I can't recommend this new spot enough. A perfect addition to the neighborhood!

G
Gina C.